|  JEI Home  |  JTAS  |  Email JEI  |  ISEIS  |

Journal of Environmental Informatics

Online ISSN 1684-8799 / Print ISSN 1726-2135

JEI Operating Procedure

Guideline for Reviewers

PDF   Word

online review form

---

Reviewer's name:

Email address:    

Manuscript Number:   

---

Please rate the manuscript in following categories:

Importance Select one Excellent Good Fair Poor Very Poor        Originality  Select one Excellent Good Fair Poor Very Poor       Organization Excellent Select one Good Fair Poor Very Poor

Clarity       Select one Excellent Good Fair Poor Very Poor         Accuracy  Select one Excellent Good Fair Poor Very Poor       Methodology Select one Excellent Good Fair Poor Very Poor

Results     Select one Excellent Good Fair Poor Very Poor   Interpretation  Select one Excellent Good Fair Poor Very Poor         References Select one Excellent Good Fair Poor Very Poor

---

OVERALL RECOMMENDATION:

Accept without revision

Accept subject to minor revision

Accept with major revision

Reject but may resubmit

Reject

---

Comments to the editors: This part is confidential, and only presented to the editors.

 

---

Comments to the Author: Please do not make any specific statement about acceptability of the paper in this part.

 

 

   

© 2010 ISEIS - International Society for Environmental Information Sciences